Lateral-g Forums

Lateral-g Forums (https://www.lateral-g.net/forums/index.php)
-   Open Discussion (https://www.lateral-g.net/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=14)
-   -   Big problem with my power dyno numbers (https://www.lateral-g.net/forums/showthread.php?t=10701)

camcojb 08-13-2007 09:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TOM NELSON
340 to the ground is probally about 460 hp.I would check a couple of things one do you have 9 pounds in the manifold at your peak rpm serpentines will slip and if it does the car will feel soft as hell.Two with 9 psi even on a 8.5 to 1 350 with the hot cam you should be making at the very least 580 hp crank and you would definately feel that.I'm not sure if you said your transmission but if it's a auto are you sure it's not sliping,just a thought.Run a compression check on all cylinders see if there within 10 percent of each other and at least 110 pounds cranking.If you have that than i doubt it's in the motor.I've had problems with the procharger units I actually have not used your blower before though but in the past there smaller blowers just did not cut it.I had a 383 with a blower i believe was similar to yours lay down 310 to the ground.We changed pulleys you name it.Not big improvements .Switched to a ysi vortech it picked up 400 hp.and made 710 to the ground and the cam was much smaller than your hot cam.I had good luck with there bigger units like the f2's but even there above 10 psi they really start making heat fast.Ignition Timing can be a huge deal on a 8.5 to 1 motor I've seen 100hp from 25 to 35 degrees the low compression engines like timing at 9 psi and only 6000 rpm But beware carbs timing and boost is a scary deal.If it was mine and i felt good about the tuner i would not shy away from 35degrees total timing at 9si and 6000 rpm this can literally transform the engine.Again beware creap up on it.I would for ****s put some 110 in it and put total at 35 dgrees and see what happens given afr's are in the high 11's low 12's.Hope you fiqure it out

Tom, with his BTM he's only got about 15 degrees of timing at WOT and full boost. I think this is a huge power killer, and gave the dyno guy a couple other things to try. Bottom line, he's got to get more timing in the thing, if that takes water injection or whatever.

Jody

mazspeed 08-13-2007 09:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by camcojb
Tom, with his BTM he's only got about 15 degrees of timing at WOT and full boost. I think this is a huge power killer, and gave the dyno guy a couple other things to try. Bottom line, he's got to get more timing in the thing, if that takes water injection or whatever.

Jody

Hey Jody, do you think with better cooler airflow, would allow for higher timing settings?

camcojb 08-13-2007 10:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mazspeed
Hey Jody, do you think with better cooler airflow, would allow for higher timing settings?

absolutely. Cooler air (through intercooling, water-alcohol injection, and to a degree a cold air intake) will all allow more timing and/or boost.

Jody

Blown353 08-13-2007 10:15 PM

15 degrees is VERY low timing. I would keep bumping it up and keep a close eye on the power numbers and the plugs. I'd be willing to bet it will run best somewhere between 24 and 30 degrees under boost on 91 octane. You're probably leaving 75-100hp on the table running only 15 degrees of timing under boost.

What heatrange plugs are you running? Keep an eye on that too as you bump up the timing. If your heads use 3/4 reach gasketed plugs I'd say you will probably end up with something equivalent to an NGK BKR6ES, that should be about right for that compression and 9 psi of boost. Maybe even one step hotter at 5ES, but start with the colder ones.

With my blowthrough carb setup on 91 octane I was running the distributor locked at 36 degrees, plus another 14 degrees possible with vacuum advance. The BTM box pulled it down to 27 degrees at 15 psi of boost. That's with 15 psi of boost, no intercooler, 9.25:1 compression, and water injection.

Another thing, don't trust the knob on the BTM. Start the engine and run it and use a hand pump with an accurate gauge to apply pressure to the BTM at your maximum boost level, then adjust the knob to your desired timing number while watching the pointer with a timing light. Obviously, do this with your vacuum advance disconnected and at a high enough RPM so the distributor is "all in" if you have the centrifugal advance hooked up. The numbers on the knob aren't really that accurate. In the ballpark, yes, but not exact. I did this on my BTM and made new tick marks on the knob every 0.5 degrees per PSI of *actual* retard as verified by the hand pump and timing light.

mazspeed 08-13-2007 10:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by camcojb
absolutely. Cooler air (through intercooling, water-alcohol injection, and to a degree a cold air intake) will all allow more timing and/or boost.

Jody

Ok second question, would more airflow allow for more timing even if it's the same temp?

mazspeed 08-13-2007 10:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Blown353
15 degrees is VERY low timing. I would keep bumping it up and keep a close eye on the power numbers and the plugs. I'd be willing to bet it will run best somewhere between 24 and 30 degrees under boost on 91 octane. You're probably leaving 75-100hp on the table running only 15 degrees of timing under boost.

What heatrange plugs are you running? Keep an eye on that too as you bump up the timing.

With my blowthrough carb setup on 91 octane I was running the distributor locked at 36 degrees, plus another 14 degrees possible with vacuum advance. The BTM box pulled it down to 27 degrees at 15 psi of boost. That's with 15 psi of boost, no intercooler, 9.25:1 compression, and water injection.

Another thing, don't trust the knob on the BTM. Start the engine and run it and use a hand pump with an accurate gauge to apply pressure to it to the BTM simulate your maximum boost, then adjust the knob to your desired timing number while watching the pointer with a timing light. The numbers on the knob aren't really that accurate. In the ballpark, yes, but not exact.

I agree with the knob, but I do have fast burn heads. Do you think that the fast burn heads require less timing under boost? I heard that they do under N/A.

Blown353 08-13-2007 10:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mazspeed
I agree with the knob, but I do have fast burn heads. Do you think that the fast burn heads require less timing under boost? I heard that they do under N/A.

I've never messed with fastburns and boost, but N/A they seem to work well with about 2-4 degrees less timing than a "standard" chamber 23 degree head. I would venture to guess they would also need slightly less timing under boost as well, but probably not 15 degrees low.

However, the only way to tell is to make more passes and keep a close eye on the plugs. Being non-intercooled I'd keep the AFR in the 11.7-11.8:1 range. If the AFR holds steady then add timing and make another pull then check the plugs and look for signs of detonation. If things look good, add more timing and repeat as necessary. Be sure to check ALL the plugs. When I was running my RPM Air-Gap in blowthrough I recall 2 cylinders being leaner than the others so I had to tune for those two cylinders. It was 1 on each bank that was leaner than the rest. I can't remember which unfortunately. That's where the single plane will help.

I'd be real interested to see what your EGT's are with 15 degrees of timing. :willy:

mazspeed 08-14-2007 09:21 AM

Took off the filter and gained 37hp. Also it was much cooler today. It was not the filter. Car is going back to Campbell today. I have no idea what to do at this point.

Blown353 08-14-2007 09:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mazspeed
Took off the filter and gained 37hp. Also it was much cooler today. It was not the filter. Car is going back to Campbell today. I have no idea what to do at this point.

37hp gain just by removing the air filter is good. Did they also try a pull in the cooler air with the filter on?

I'm still guessing there's another 50+ hp on the table with the timing so low at 15 degrees.

mazspeed 08-14-2007 09:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Blown353
37hp gain just by removing the air filter is good. Did they also try a pull in the cooler air with the filter on?

I'm still guessing there's another 50+ hp on the table with the timing so low at 15 degrees.

37hp was because they did it in the morning on a cold run. once everything is heat soaked the power would drop again. There should be 150 left on the table. We should have 500ft pounds at the wheels with this boost and engine configuration.

camcojb 08-14-2007 09:49 AM

do not underestimate the power loss of no timing. Have them switch it over to the 104 fuel and put the 28 degrees in with no retard. Then you'll know where you could be with water injection. As a matter of fact, I can't believe you cannot run 30-32 degrees with that boost level and 104 octane gas.

Jody

Steve Chryssos 08-14-2007 09:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mazspeed
....I have no idea what to do at this point.

Get Jody to put on his cape & tights and fly over.

mazspeed 08-14-2007 10:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by camcojb
do not underestimate the power loss of no timing. Have them switch it over to the 104 fuel and put the 28 degrees in with no retard. Then you'll know where you could be with water injection. As a matter of fact, I can't believe you cannot run 30-32 degrees with that boost level and 104 octane gas.

Jody

Hey Jody. I'm aware of the fast burn heads not needing as much timing as other setups, but I do not know if this is also the case with a boosted setup. Ill ask them to do that today.

mazspeed 08-14-2007 10:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by streetfytr68
Get Jody to put on his cape & tights and fly over.

I wish.

Blown353 08-14-2007 10:11 AM

Hell, I'd drive over there today if I wasn't stuck here at work. I'm only about 85 miles away from Campbell and Jody's only about another 15 miles further than me.

He would have to ride in the trunk though if he was wearing a cape and tights. :lol:

mazspeed 08-14-2007 10:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Blown353
Hell, I'd drive over there today if I wasn't stuck here at work. I'm only about 85 miles away from Campbell and Jody's only about another 15 miles further than me.

He would have to ride in the trunk though if he was wearing a cape and tights. :lol:

heheh :lol:

I think though that I'm just going to sell it and get out of the car game. It has been really bugging me to the point of where I cannot sleep at night, and I have a family and a company to run and I just cannot deal with this car anymore.

Steve Chryssos 08-14-2007 10:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mazspeed
I agree with the knob, but I do have fast burn heads. Do you think that the fast burn heads require less timing under boost? I heard that they do under N/A.

Don't get distracted, your heads are fine. Fast-burn simply means kidney bean shaped chamber as opposed to old school open style. The shape helps move the combustion process towards the spark plug and then exhaust valve, thereby aiding, or speeding up, the process of moving the mixture in, burning it, and pushing it out. So the logic is reversed: Fast burn heads can accomplish the same goals with less timing. Doesn't mean they can't tolerate timing.

Mike,
Sounds like you have some real good help in your neck of the woods. Focus on problems associated with your blower install. Collect your data and get with ProCharger and the Carb Shop.

67SuperSnake 08-14-2007 10:51 AM

I realize I have a totally different motor (427FE, Fast EFI, etc), but 15 degrees timing is very low. I am running 38 degrees, 10lbs boost, EFI backs out 1 degree for every pound of boost. Using Diamond blower pistons. NGK BKR6ES (I think this is the same plug I am using, but for sure a 6).

Remember that engines are just big air pumps. Everything you have in the way of intake or exhaust restrictions can and will affect it to some degree. I know a guy who has an engine dyno in his garage and does a lot of testing on S/C. He just changed the hat from a lower type to a well round type and gained 100hp.

Similar to this one:

http://www.stevemorrisracingengines....carb-hat-1.jpg

rich-allen 08-14-2007 11:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mazspeed
heheh :lol:

I think though that I'm just going to sell it and get out of the car game. It has been really bugging me to the point of where I cannot sleep at night, and I have a family and a company to run and I just cannot deal with this car anymore.

Oh dammit man!!! Don't give up on her yet. Obviously you have a lot of time and money into this project, hell just look at the website you built with all those pictures!

You probably can't sleep because you love that car and you want it to perform like you dreamed of it performing the entire time.. If your seriously at the point of throwing in the towel, put it on a trailer and send it to someone who can tune it properly. When it's finished have them send it back.

Rich

TOM NELSON 08-14-2007 12:22 PM

15 degrees
 
15 degrees of timing not only is it not enough it's not safe it will hold to much heat and want to pop the head gaskets.From 15 degrees to a very safe 32 degrees with gas you will ****tttt yourself on the difference.Give it a try.Disconnect the boost retard completely set the total timing to 32 degrees look at the light yourself so you no for sure its there .to be sure make sure the motor is at 3500 to 4000 rpm when your setting the timing and if you have vac advance unplug it when setting.Pour some high test over 100 octane and let it rip.The fast burn head gives you a advantage of being able to run more timing if wanted.This motor on 91 should easily be able to run 30 degrees safely at 8.5 to 1 at 9 pounds.You would freak out if you saw a timing curve i run at 38 psi.Ive run as much as 40 it all depends on the motor but 15 not enough.I think weve all been where your at one time or another.When i first started making turbo engines i listened to all the turbo experts and built probally 6 different engines and burned 100's of gallons of racing fuel to only make 600hp with a tt sbc.I just about threw in the towel.It sucks but you will get it the parts are there and 500ft to the tire should be no problem at all.try the timing first.If no improvement compression it.If you like feel free to call me Have a good one Tom

mazspeed 08-14-2007 12:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rich-allen
Oh dammit man!!! Don't give up on her yet. Obviously you have a lot of time and money into this project, hell just look at the website you built with all those pictures!

You probably can't sleep because you love that car and you want it to perform like you dreamed of it performing the entire time.. If your seriously at the point of throwing in the towel, put it on a trailer and send it to someone who can tune it properly. When it's finished have them send it back.

Rich

Hey Rich, thanks for the words, but I can no longer afford this car in the way it's going. It's going to cost a lot more money and time to fix and I just don't have it in me to continue. I just spent 15k for a rehab facility for my sister yesterday for her alcohol and drug problems, work is a little slow this summer with the housing market the way it is, and I just cannot continue to move foward with this nightmare any longer. CAR is going to want to charge me god knows what to fix this for something that should have been thought about before we went forward with this. I don't think the car is going to be reliable when it's done if it's ever done. And I don't think Ill ever get a chance to enjoy the car this year, I think it's just time to cut my losses. I don't know what else to do.

Rob07002 08-14-2007 12:31 PM

Mike, don't lose faith, your car is awsome!

We've all been ready to throw in the towel at least once. Take comfort in knowing you have lots of support here and real pro's like Tom willing to offer advice and time.

Take a mini-vacation from her and jump back in, in a few weeks.

I wish I knew more to help you, but I am blower-dumb.

GT500KR_Vert 08-14-2007 12:39 PM

Don't give up, getting these cars right or even finished is stressful and a PITA. I've been wokring on mine for 3 years. The hardest part is getting the guys who do work on it to do it right and actually put the time in to get it done.

Quote:

Originally Posted by mazspeed
Hey Rich, thanks for the words, but I can no longer afford this car in the way it's going. It's going to cost a lot more money and time to fix and I just don't have it in me to continue. I just spent 15k for a rehab facility for my sister yesterday for her alcohol and drug problems, work is a little slow this summer with the housing market the way it is, and I just cannot continue to move foward with this nightmare any longer. CAR is going to want to charge me god knows what to fix this for something that should have been thought about before we went forward with this. I don't think the car is going to be reliable when it's done if it's ever done. And I don't think Ill ever get a chance to enjoy the car this year, I think it's just time to cut my losses. I don't know what else to do.


3kidsnotime 08-14-2007 12:53 PM

I havent been on in quite some time, I see anything on ATI (procharger) I feel I need to chine in... I hope you dont give up on the car stick it in the corner for a week and forget about it.. sometimes it needs to be done.
Your getting alot of great advice on this Tom has some greas input as well as Jody, I have literally sold and installed hundreads of these units more in the marine field but also in automotive as well and just about any internal combustion engine i could mess with. http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm...endid=68611071 I have alot of pics on there you can look at. I also did some R&D for Dan Jones when he started the company for a number of years and its a great product you just need to cover some basics. All the input your getting is great I wont knock any just tell you some basics to fallow on a carb deal.
1 Boost read it after vacume.
2 Fuel boost reference before vacume make sure your at 1 extra pound fuel for every pound of boost.
3 Timing dont go too low you will hurt it worse. I like to lock out on 29 total I do not take timing out under 28 under psi your engine should be just fine.
4 Make sure your belt is tight VERY TIGHT Comon Problem!
5 Remember it takes power to turn your head unit low boost might only be making the added power to turn it hence almost equal from the begining so a slipping belt will just make it fall on its face at RPM
Those are some of the top problems we see your base engine is just fine for adding psi to it and they are very easy to tune most people over think it and miss the obvious.
I would go out crank the timing up make sure the belt is very tight and take it for a burn down the street Good Luck Jeff

rich-allen 08-14-2007 12:59 PM

If things are getting that scary, maybe you should put the car in the garage and cover it up for a month or two. It wont hurt you to store it until you come to a final decision.
Selling the car sounds easy but you will stir up an entirely different set a emotions and problems when you actually do it. There's not a lot of people with the cash to buy someones dream.

Last time I checked, a mans dream is worth quite a bit of money. :yes:


I hope everything works out for you,

Rich

ProdigyCustoms 08-14-2007 01:19 PM

Just a thought. With all the offers of help. Why not accept 353 or Jody's help and see if one of them could spend a day with you at the dyno. Taking it to Campbell, to adjust tiing is crazy. I know those are great guys, but you have a few serious ProCharger experts throwing advice your way.

I bet it is a hell of a lot less money to pay 353s fuel then one hour in a shop.

Rybar 08-14-2007 03:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ProdigyCustoms
Just a thought. With all the offers of help. Why not accept 353 or Jody's help and see if one of them could spend a day with you at the dyno. Taking it to Campbell, to adjust tiing is crazy. I know those are great guys, but you have a few serious ProCharger experts throwing advice your way.

I bet it is a hell of a lot less money to pay 353s fuel then one hour in a shop.

I agree with Frank, ask for help from some friends and this board, you never know how much labor some beer and food can buy you. Good luck with the motor Mike, but don't give up so fast, you have an awesome car and were all supporting you and trying to help. :cheers:

69bird 08-14-2007 04:18 PM

1 Attachment(s)
I don't live far away and in the san jose area for work all the time. I'm a hvac contractor I see your a electrical contractor. I would be willing to help you out anyway I can. I was ready to give up on my car too before or go to a ls1.Sometimes a new set of eyes on a problem is a good thing. I have a simlar setup on my firebird. I did go to efi because my carb was giving me a hard time. Heres a pic of my setup.

V8TV 08-14-2007 04:20 PM

I understand how you probably want to drive this thing off a cliff, but you'll probably be more upset if you sell it.

Perhaps the most aggravating thing is how you thought it was going to be right from the beginning, and now you have to go back and mess with it more! But unfortunately, that can be part of the game. Heck, it seems I have to do everything twice... at LEAST twice!

But the payoff is when it all comes together.

Don't overlook the basics, too. Triple check everything. I've personally seen a C5 Corvette with a Vortech pick up 65 HP (yes, 65!) just by letting it cool, changing to cheap NGK plugs over platinums, and adding a few degrees of timing.

Saw the same thing happen at a tune session with the SN65 Mustang. Temp, plugs, and timing added a big jump.

Seeing that this is all chassis dyno, how's the clutch?

You are getting some great advice from some real experts here - hang in there, and you'll be rewarded when you figure it out. And not to sound like a d***, but if you do have to sell it, you'll get more $ with a bigger dyno sheet!

- KO

69bird 08-14-2007 04:21 PM

Just wondering what kind of fuel system are you running?

youthpastor 08-14-2007 05:31 PM

I agree with just about every post

don't think so hard...the car is killer (we've all been there- take a break)

15 degrees is not enough to move my lawn mower, MAJOR power killer and heat producer

it is JUST an air pump- u gotta get the spark there to make the thing rev..

I would hate to see you sell the car (you have inspired a lot of us with the build)
still working on my 68. I know the whole wheel issue would have been enough for me, but hang in there:thumbsup:

jeff s 08-14-2007 05:37 PM

Does the carb still have a choke housing on it?
If so, with that low hat, there will be a huge restriction.
I've also seen 60-100 rwhp increase with a little more timing on a boosted engine.

Blown353 08-14-2007 05:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jeff s
Does the carb still have a choke housing on it?
If so, with that low hat, there will be a huge restriction.
I've also seen 60 rwhp increase with a little more timing on a boosted engine.

Jeff, I don't believe that ATI low hat will even fit if the choke housing is still in place... it's only about 1" off the sealing flange of the carb on the inside... But that's still a good question.

As I mentioned several pages ago, even if the current and obviously major problem isn't directly related to that carb hat he could pick up quite a bit of power by going to a good hat. That ATI low hat is pretty mediocre.

markss28 08-14-2007 06:02 PM

dude do not get rid of it you really dont need to spend any money at all. Try th timing in the garage and take it out for a spin this is very simple to do and you should feel the power kick in. Yu are right at the point where most of us would like to be.

stick with it stick with it stick with it stick with it stick with it stick with it

V8TV 08-14-2007 06:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by markss28
Yu are right at the point where most of us would like to be.

stick with it stick with it stick with it stick with it stick with it stick with it

:cheers:

mdprovee 08-14-2007 06:28 PM

Mike,

Just set the car aside for a while...I too have been frustrated..it's been 14 years since mine was running. Keep your chin up, and take a break.

Besides the new owner may not give me a ride.

JamesJ 08-14-2007 06:42 PM

You have gotten 76 replys in 28 hours, that says people care. It was said before i bet some members would love to come to your house this weekend and help you with it. the only problem is they may not leave!

Ummgawa 08-14-2007 07:33 PM

Mike

You have guys here that are in magazines every month. Guys that hang out with the Big Dogs in our hobby. You have heard from a good amount of those here. Listen to them. All I can offer is this: Park it in a cool dry spot and let it sit until this passes. There are a lot of us with high 5 figures in a car that we have not even heard run yet. You are so far past the majority of us. Hang in there man, take some offers of help, or cover it and sit it in the corner. Trust me, if you sell, the guy that gets the deal will go that extra inch you need right now and have a wicked killer ride THAT YOU BUILT!

68protouring454 08-14-2007 07:57 PM

take members help, obviously c.a.r.s did not do anyhomework setting the motor up, as any guys i talk to say the ati hats suck, you'll get it, i would just talk to them about the situation, you did not build it to have these issues, goodluck its probably still pissed at you for doing those donuts near traffic!!

kp.touring 08-14-2007 08:37 PM

Power
 
Well I've been quite, but here I go. In re-but to no doing our home work were do you get off with that. People are throw theirr 2 cents in and those ideas were look at from the start. What we have here is a packaging problem, there is no room for a taller hat over the carb. We know the hat is not helping power, also a single plan intake would work better and ducting the air inlet to get air from outside the car would be awesome, but now we are back to packaging. The other thing is Ca's crap gas we may have 91 oct but it doesn't have the btu's that other areas have so yes our numbers are not going to be those high earth shaking numbers.
Bottom line is Mike's car does have more in it, given time to tune and add some way to cool the air inlet charge it will get there as this was the car's first tuning on the Super Flow dyno. And just a note with anymore timing the engine started to pre-ignite, so we are looking strongly at water injection.
Wish we had room for a intercooler.
Kevin
C.A.R.


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 02:05 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Copyright Lateral-g.net