In the Raleigh/Durham area I'd use B Mac's Restoration. I've seen 5 cars now from rust & dust to near perfection. They don't do shows, magazines but always have a full booking. I'll recommend them because I've crawled around the work in progress and know they don't cut corners in areas that get covered up and never seen.
http://www.bmacsrestoration.com/index.html
Beyond that I'd give DSE a recommendation, having done a shop tour, but they're not really a body shop for small/partial jobs.
Any ways good luck I know there are good shops represented in this forum and you'll quickly find customers that can provide piece of mind.