View Single Post
  #15  
Old 02-22-2010, 08:58 AM
DocJr's Avatar
DocJr DocJr is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Hagerstown, MD
Posts: 92
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Default

LOL Greg, If I hated you after that comment, that would be pathetic. Good Designers shouldn't get THAT offended haha.

However, a good critique needs to have reason. If you don't mind me diggin' in a little bit, could you try to explain why it looks the way it does to you? Is it my take on the aar cuda stripe? (shape, spacing, ect) because the intent was NOT to copy it line for line. Or would you say the same thing about an orange AAR Cuda? lol

I can understand if you feel it just wouldnt work, it's a muscle car stripe going on a '62 Impala...That was the challange though, Prowler Orange, Charcoal Grey, and something similar to the AAR Cuda stripe. Maybe it would look better thinned out (as far as height), and not taking it completely down to the body line?

T-Type, I see what you're saying about both trim and stripe...the trim is horizontal, the stripe combo is vertical...still, through my eyes, I don't see the complication, afterall, the stripe is contained within the trim, and the main bodyline of the car. That's not saying they couldn't shave the trim, that would reveal the upper bodyline, hmm. Thanks for your feedback man.

Agian, I don't get offended by critiiqe, I find it very insightful. At the same time however I do believe in the saying, that I can't please everyone haha If my client is happy, that's all that matters. Maybe with the next projects I'll show you guys the preliminary sketches, that way you guys could help with the decision making process.

Like I said before...Keep the feedback coming! and thanks!
__________________
Nelson - Designer/Artist
Prices are the same regardless of who you are, low.
Reply With Quote