Quote:
Originally Posted by camcojb
First off, your example of a 4.6 Ford with 160# injectors is not something that's seen every day.  Yeah, with that large of an injector idle issues are a concern.
I have not had a single idle issue yet doing it my way. I've never had the pulsewidth go "too low" at idle and cause issues. I've never "chased" the tuning because of this.
You seem to take it personally that I have made it work well in a way different than you think it should be. You've given good advice, I see the purpose of referencing the regulator. But with a rear mounted regulator it's just one more line to run, plus I'm not sure there may not be an issue with the length of the line. Couldn't see an issue with the forced induction builds and the line length, but never tried on N/A.
I don't try to hand out bad info, I simply try to help with things that work for me. I have no problem with your view and would recommend people follow your advice, you're the pro. What I don't agree with is you keep saying that the reference line must be used. That's where you lose credibility. It's obvious that it isn't required or none of my cars or any of the other examples in this thread would run. I mean, they wouldn't even start up according to the "must" claim. That's my point. |
I have tuned 4 ~ 4.6 Fords this week that had that same combo. You are chasing the fuel curve weather you want to believe it or not.. that is fine. Take it personally... no not at all, you just don't seem to get it. One more line to run is no big deal... it's just cheap vac line... line length shouldn't matter.
It's not my credibility... it would be yours to keep arguing that it really does not matter. If you really understood what was happening you would say... I will always do it that way now that I understand. To tell people bad information that is does not matter or everyone here has always done it this way and it worked isn't a good argument.
I never said an engine wouldn't start.. or run... just not "right" most EZ EFI systems wont run very well at all. The real problem is where you try to lean out the idle down around the 1.2-1.4 ms of PW and you keep getting a rich condition you can't get out.
Like I said, you can machine an engine with .008 piston to wall clearance.. would it run.. sure.. but would you do that? No.. So if you now it is better and the proper way to run the regulator with the vac line then why wouldn’t you?
Lets face it the industry is full of people who see one thing and copy everyone else who is doing it that way. If the points leader uses brand X oil then it must be the best stuff out there. If this guy uses these gaskets then everyone should use that gasket. There is more bad info out there than there is good especially in the EFI world. My day usually consists of helping people tune their stuff after 5 other guys just took their money and gave them the tune out of the XFI folder. Part of why I have done well as a EFI tuner is I do a lot of dyno testing trying different stuff and have access to some really cool datalogging stuff most people don't even get to play with ever. I try to help out on a few boards and offer advise on what works and what does not. If I see something people don't get or understand then I try to help them in the right direction at least. This topic is something that I cover in every EFI101 class I teach and usually get blank stares from the students that say... wow everyone else does not do that. When I draw a picture on the board... most get it. There is lots of other stuff like, adding fuel stops detonation.... fuel is power... lots of stuff we debunk on the chassis dyno live at our classes.
Not taking anything personally and not talking down to anyone just trying to educate some bad info.