Quote:
Originally Posted by Woody
Greg,
You have really opened my eyes to investing in stocks. Up until now I have been investing most of my retirement funds in mutual funds. I own six funds right now and have my money evenly divided between small cap, mid-cap and large cap funds. I was just doing some research on the ten year performance of my funds. The ten year total returns (including dividends) has ranged from 22% to 147% with an average return of 68%. That equates to roughly 6.8% per year (simple interest).
Just for comparison sake, I took 12 stocks, most of which have been mentioned in this thread and calculated ten year total returns (including dividends) The stocks included were HD, PFE, CVX, MCD, MO, KFT, JNJ, KO, T, KMB, PG and CAT. Ten year returns ranged from -2% to 383% and averaged 143% which is approximately 14.3%, more than double my mutual funds average return.
I have reviewed the stock holdings of my mutual funds and I believe I own all of the stocks mentioned within the mutual funds. However, the funds also own 100+ other stocks, some of which I have no clue as to what they do.
Anyway, this has been a real eye opener for me. Thanks again for your insight.
|
Fantastic work Woody!!
This really is so simple ANYONE can do it -- but somehow we'd rather "leave it alone" or ignore it altogether...
So you just summed up WHY I THINK MUTUAL FUNDS SUCK.... because they're not going to buy anything you can't on your own... but there PERFORMANCE will be pulled down because of DILUTION.... They can't just own the best of breed -- they're just going to buy EVERYTHING... because most are simply set up to mimic some "standard" -- whether it's the S&P 500 or some other index. Then they churn the stocks -- and charge you fees for all this... and in the meantime you have no idea what's what.
If you can buy 10 to 20 top stocks - you have a mutual fund. No fees. And you are in control.
Mutual funds were great for people -- they get a job -- and they can "save" $50 or $100 per paycheck... so they have a "place"... but you can do better on your own as soon as you have 10 grand or so.