Alex LaRue. He deals all day with these classic cars. Agreed upon value. I said I wanted my Chevelle insured for $40K and he said no problem. He was even standing there when I was auto-crossing my car, all insured.

Worth a shot to give him a call:

http://www.larueinsurance.net/larueins.html

I just signed up with Alex as well. Good guy, definitely a car guy, and the process was simple. Pricing was very good for an agreed value policy with 6k miles per year, and a couple of days a week of driving to work if I want. :)