camaro doors? re skin or not

[fxstdale]

need some advice on doors on my car, both doors on m car have a lot of mud in them, not rusty except for a small dime spot on one door. other door was hit long ago and has a crease in it. my body guy wants to fix both doors insted of skining them due to the fact there orginial. theres a 1/8 inch coat on half the doors now. car has new quarters, taillight panel, and ds fender. all goodmark. my thinking is skin them what do you think?