...

Go Back   Lateral-g Forums > Technical Discussions > EFI and Forced Induction
User Name
Password



Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 12-11-2011, 06:30 AM
supremeefi supremeefi is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2010
Location: Central fl
Posts: 180
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Blown353 View Post
Good point-- I forgot to mention that as well. That's what I get for posting in a hurry from work. LOL!

A mixture that's far too lean during overrun can cause the mixture not to burn or not completely burn in the cylinders and instead the unburned fuel will build up and burn/pop in the exhaust.

It does take a little trial and error to find best amount of fuel to greatly reduce or eliminate the overrun pops. Datalogging will at least show you which cells you need to concentrate on for mixture, timing, and O2 correction limit tweaks.

Going too lean in the overrun areas can also cause a "dead spot" in the pedal at very slight throttle angle changes when transitioning out of overrun.

I still wonder why FAST hasn't added a DFCO function after all these years... it's not something that's necessary but it would sure be nice to have-- and it seems like 98% of the other ECUs out there offer it.
That's a great question, probably why Accel hasn't added "self learning". Let me tell you why.
I asked Accel a couple of years ago about adding "self learing", the answer is simple.
Most EFI's in this class use the same capacity boards, they'll only hold/do so much, period. Big Stuff has more dataloging than most others out there, but did you ever see their transient fueling tables? They suck, I think there's 3 of them. FAST now has self learning and some other "new" stuff. But again there are other things they had to leave out. Accel doesn't have self learning but has more transient fueling tables than anyone, and have you ever used their nitrous tables? I don't think they get any easier, enter the pill size and bottle pressure and it does the fuel map for you, and it's damn close.
So what do you give up? In the case of Accel, do you give up the transient tables etc that imo make it drive better than anything in this price range, or does BS3 give up their datalogging capacity that makes them a drag racers favorite? Tough choices.

Every system has some limitations, it just depends on what's important to you and your application. I have no trouble tuning the Accel without the self learning feature, I wouldn't give up the potential driveability for anything.
__________________
Mark
Engine builder and tuner.
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 12-11-2011, 07:59 AM
camcojb's Avatar
camcojb camcojb is offline
Administrator
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Wilton, CA.
Posts: 13,475
Thanks: 7,718
Thanked 2,362 Times in 1,104 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by supremeefi View Post
That's a great question, probably why Accel hasn't added "self learning". Let me tell you why.
I asked Accel a couple of years ago about adding "self learing", the answer is simple.
Most EFI's in this class use the same capacity boards, they'll only hold/do so much, period. Big Stuff has more dataloging than most others out there, but did you ever see their transient fueling tables? They suck, I think there's 3 of them. FAST now has self learning and some other "new" stuff. But again there are other things they had to leave out. Accel doesn't have self learning but has more transient fueling tables than anyone, and have you ever used their nitrous tables? I don't think they get any easier, enter the pill size and bottle pressure and it does the fuel map for you, and it's damn close.
So what do you give up? In the case of Accel, do you give up the transient tables etc that imo make it drive better than anything in this price range, or does BS3 give up their datalogging capacity that makes them a drag racers favorite? Tough choices.

Every system has some limitations, it just depends on what's important to you and your application. I have no trouble tuning the Accel without the self learning feature, I wouldn't give up the potential driveability for anything.
That's good info Mark. I'd like to tune the new Accel some day. The Gen VII was not a favorite of mine, BECAUSE of those transient fueling tables and overall complexity of the overlapping of tables. That TAU vs table was not understood by any of the Accel tech guys or the EMIC's. Also not a fan of having the pro key and the cost to buy the key. My buddy's car was a procharged 406 and I don't remember what, but there was something in there we had to tweak to fix an issue. Wasted a bunch of time tuning before we were told about that area.

It was the hardest system for me to tune that I've encountered. Easy to get up and running, but hard to get perfect. We would shut certain things off trying to isolate something, and then in datalogs you'd see they were still working (think it was the O2 correction, been too long to remember).The one we had on a friends car was finally sold after a year and replaced with Fast, and ran great.

I assume the new stuff is not like this? My friend has completely re-done that car and now has a 500 rwhp LS motor in it, and we have not decided on an engine management system yet for it.
__________________
Jody

PAST CAR PROJECTS

Like Lateral-G on Facebook!

Follow Lateral-G on Instagram!

SPECIAL THANKS TO:
Jacob Ehlers and Amsoil for the lubricants and degreasers for my 70 Chevelle project
Shannon at Modo Innovations for the cool billet DBW bracket
Roadster Shop for their Chevelle SPEC Chassis
Dakota Digital for their Chevelle HDX Gauge Package
Painless Performance for their wiring harness

Ron Davis Radiators for their radiator and fan assembly.
Baer Brakes for their front and rear brakes

Texas Speed and Performance for their 427 LS Stroker
American Powertrain for their ProFit Magnum T56 kit
Currie Enterprises for their 9" Third Member
Forgeline for their GF3 Wheels
McLeod Racing for their RXT street twin clutch
Ididit for their steering column
Holley for their EFI and engine parts
Lokar and Clayton Machine for their pedals and door and window handles
Morris Classic Concepts for their 3 point belts and side mirrors
Thermotec for their heat sleeve and sound deadening products
Restomod Air for their Tru Mod A/C kit
Mightymouse Solutions for their catch can
Magnaflow for their 3" exhaust system
Aeromotive for their dual Phantom fuel system
Vintage Air for their new Mid Mount LS front drive
Hydratech Braking for their hydroboost system
Borgeson for their stainless steering shaft and u joints
Eddie Motorsports for their hood and trunk hinges and misc parts
TMI Products for their seats, door panels, and dash pad
Rock Valley Antique Auto Parts for their stainless fuel tank
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 12-11-2011, 10:00 AM
supremeefi supremeefi is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2010
Location: Central fl
Posts: 180
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by camcojb View Post
That's good info Mark. I'd like to tune the new Accel some day. The Gen VII was not a favorite of mine, BECAUSE of those transient fueling tables and overall complexity of the overlapping of tables. That TAU vs table was not understood by any of the Accel tech guys or the EMIC's. Also not a fan of having the pro key and the cost to buy the key. My buddy's car was a procharged 406 and I don't remember what, but there was something in there we had to tweak to fix an issue. Wasted a bunch of time tuning before we were told about that area.

It was the hardest system for me to tune that I've encountered. Easy to get up and running, but hard to get perfect. We would shut certain things off trying to isolate something, and then in datalogs you'd see they were still working (think it was the O2 correction, been too long to remember).The one we had on a friends car was finally sold after a year and replaced with Fast, and ran great.

I assume the new stuff is not like this? My friend has completely re-done that car and now has a 500 rwhp LS motor in it, and we have not decided on an engine management system yet for it.
I'd be happy to help Jody. Unfortunately there are too many "EMICs" that don't have a clue, on any system. There are progressions that you need to follow, and if you do I promise you the rest falls into place. I've had guys tell me that this or that system makes more peak power, that's because that's the system they know the best. x amount of spark/fuel will make x amount of peak power, period. However the curve in getting there can be made more beneficial with the right system and tuner. I've tuned some FAST, Holley and MSD Blaster/BS3, I'll take the Accel over them any day. Imo the others just don't have the features/software to maximize the hp/tq curve.

P.S. you can turn most anything off on the Accel system if you like, even the O2. And they came up with the Pro key option because too many people were fooling with stuff they didn't need to fool with, that's also the reason for the Thruster. But guess what, you can still access all the GenIIV stuff thru that software, even though on the surface the Thruster seems "dumbed down".
__________________
Mark
Engine builder and tuner.

Last edited by supremeefi; 12-11-2011 at 10:07 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 12-11-2011, 10:17 AM
camcojb's Avatar
camcojb camcojb is offline
Administrator
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Wilton, CA.
Posts: 13,475
Thanks: 7,718
Thanked 2,362 Times in 1,104 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by supremeefi View Post
I'd be happy to help Jody. Unfortunately there are too many "EMICs" that don't have a clue, on any system. There are progressions that you need to follow, and if you do I promise you the rest falls into place. I've had guys tell me that this or that system makes more peak power, that's because that's the system they know the best. x amount of spark/fuel will make x amount of peak power, period. However the curve in getting there can be made more beneficial with the right system and tuner. I've tuned some FAST, Holley and MSD Blaster/BS3, I'll take the Accel over them any day. Imo the others just don't have the features/software to maximize the hp/tq curve.

P.S. you can turn most anything off on the Accel system if you like, even the O2. And they came up with the Pro key option because too many people were fooling with stuff they didn't need to fool with, that's also the reason for the Thruster. But guess what, you can still access all the GenIIV stuff thru that software, even though on the surface the Thruster seems "dumbed down".
we were turning off the O2 correction, but could still see it working. So the Gen VII is still the most advanced system they have, or is it now the Thruster? I'd never be able to talk him into the Gen VII again.......
__________________
Jody

PAST CAR PROJECTS

Like Lateral-G on Facebook!

Follow Lateral-G on Instagram!

SPECIAL THANKS TO:
Jacob Ehlers and Amsoil for the lubricants and degreasers for my 70 Chevelle project
Shannon at Modo Innovations for the cool billet DBW bracket
Roadster Shop for their Chevelle SPEC Chassis
Dakota Digital for their Chevelle HDX Gauge Package
Painless Performance for their wiring harness

Ron Davis Radiators for their radiator and fan assembly.
Baer Brakes for their front and rear brakes

Texas Speed and Performance for their 427 LS Stroker
American Powertrain for their ProFit Magnum T56 kit
Currie Enterprises for their 9" Third Member
Forgeline for their GF3 Wheels
McLeod Racing for their RXT street twin clutch
Ididit for their steering column
Holley for their EFI and engine parts
Lokar and Clayton Machine for their pedals and door and window handles
Morris Classic Concepts for their 3 point belts and side mirrors
Thermotec for their heat sleeve and sound deadening products
Restomod Air for their Tru Mod A/C kit
Mightymouse Solutions for their catch can
Magnaflow for their 3" exhaust system
Aeromotive for their dual Phantom fuel system
Vintage Air for their new Mid Mount LS front drive
Hydratech Braking for their hydroboost system
Borgeson for their stainless steering shaft and u joints
Eddie Motorsports for their hood and trunk hinges and misc parts
TMI Products for their seats, door panels, and dash pad
Rock Valley Antique Auto Parts for their stainless fuel tank
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 12-11-2011, 01:47 PM
supremeefi supremeefi is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2010
Location: Central fl
Posts: 180
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by camcojb View Post
we were turning off the O2 correction, but could still see it working. So the Gen VII is still the most advanced system they have, or is it now the Thruster? I'd never be able to talk him into the Gen VII again.......
When you turn it off, Control C, then flip the switch, the O2 area will grey out. It will still read, but won't influence the air/fuel ratio.

The Gen 7 is the big brother to the Thruster, but you can buy the Thruster, for about $400.00 less than the Gen 7, and still access most all the features of the Gen 7. They have added 4 new screens on the Gen 7 recently, all the more reason there isn't room for "self learning". Imo a decent tuner doesn't need that anyway.

It's a shame he wouldn't consider it. I know Greg Weld got caught up with a crappy tuner on Accel too, it's just a shame.
__________________
Mark
Engine builder and tuner.

Last edited by supremeefi; 12-11-2011 at 01:49 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 12-12-2011, 01:08 AM
Mathi Mathi is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Belgium, Europe
Posts: 132
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Default

Hi,

This weekend we checked everything, tables, timing, airflow stacks, etc... . Everything was as prescribed. From the moment you start (cold or warm) and you throttle just for one moment, the exhaust pops hard...

We are trying now for about 3 and a half months and we are getting frustrating!
Now, we are looking for an EFI specialist from America that want to come over to help us out. So if someone knows someone high recommended that want to come over... Everything will be paid for like flight tickets till diners, etc...
It's better to invest in a real specialist...

Regards
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 12-12-2011, 06:13 AM
supremeefi supremeefi is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2010
Location: Central fl
Posts: 180
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Default

Hi Mathi,

I would do it if it comes to that but pm me, I may have a couple guys in the U.K. that might be able to help you out. Much closer than here.
__________________
Mark
Engine builder and tuner.
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 02:19 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Copyright Lateral-g.net