Glad you found the issue....
Chalk up the "fixing parts" as part of the hot rod world...
I've hardly ever had a part that fit the way I wanted - or the first time - or that worked etc.
Friday - I was installing power windows in this 55 Chevy project I'm building for my buddy. They're the type that you use the stock window crank on - so they're really just a "momentary switch" with a return to neutral. They're like $99 EACH... so I fab a mount - got the window guts all installed ... wire up the switch just like it says to -- NO WORKIE. So scratch my head - check the instructions - yep that's all good - check the power to the switch - good - make the window go up and down with a tool that I have to supply 12Vs -- yep -- window works just like it should -- check my wiring again - hook it back up - NO WORKIE... Remove the switch - get the Fluke out - do a continuity check - get continuous continuity (3 pins on switch - A is continuous to B - which is 12V + C is ground) between A and B - activate switch with the handle - and it should disconnect A from B(12V+) - and apply 12V- from Pin C. Since there are two switches in the handle (one for up and one for down) these little micro switches need to "reverse polarity" - so either supply 12V+ to one wire to the motor - and supply 12V- to the other wire to the motor (the motor is a 2 wire motor - grounded thru the case).... BUT try as I might - no way am I getting ANYTHING out of PIN C... SO now I have to take this switch all apart -- and figure out what's wrong -- well - the eccentric has two flat spots on it - and those flat spots are what OPEN the switch (switches for this application are "normally closed")... so I have to pull the eccentric out and "flat" the spots some more until they'll let the switch open...
NOW --- ALL the previous makes little difference and I only added it to show how much work I had to do to figure out what the problem was -- and then figure out a solution. You buy a part -- hope it works - when it doesn't - you have to reverse engineer the dang thing to figure out what it's SUPPOSED TO DO - then figure out how to make it work -- OR send it back and hope the replacement (after you wait a week or two) works...
I never get mad at this kind of stuff -- I just figure it's part of "hot rodding" and in fact -- my buddies and I all just count on having to "hot rod" any parts we get.